As western states and federal agencies scramble to expand prescribed fire programs in the wake of the 2026 fire season, a new wave of reporting from Inside Climate News exposes a troubling dynamic: the same litigation culture that has forced utilities to pay billions in wildfire damages is now chilling the very prescribed burn activity that could prevent future fires.

The Litigation Problem

Wildfire litigation has become a major industry. From 2020 through 2026, Pacific Gas and Electric, Southern California Edison, and San Diego Gas and Electric ratepayers alone paid more than $35 billion in wildfire-related costs, according to a recent analysis โ€” with utility mitigation work making up the lion's share. Law firms specializing in wildfire claims have proliferated, and the threat of multimillion-dollar verdicts has made land managers โ€” including those conducting state-sanctioned prescribed burns โ€” deeply risk-averse.

"Prescribed burners say the prospect of costly litigation and rising insurance rates are complicating efforts to fight fire with fire," Inside Climate News reported on November 17. The issue is especially acute on state and private lands, which account for approximately 84% of the acreage burned by prescribed fire nationally.

The Insurance Barrier

Private burn crews and even some state agencies report difficulty obtaining insurance coverage for prescribed fire operations at any price. When coverage is available, premiums have increased sharply following several high-profile cases in which escaped prescribed burns caused property damage and triggered litigation.

Oregon and California have both established state indemnity funds to provide a backstop for certified prescribed burn managers โ€” but as of November 2026, no claims have been filed under either fund. Advocates say the funds' existence alone may be providing some market signal, with some insurers now offering coverage to private burn companies in Oregon that use the state's certified burn manager program.

The Paradox

The core paradox is stark: the same legal environment that penalizes prescribed burning โ€” which escapes occur rarely โ€” does nothing to hold anyone accountable for the far more common and far more destructive wildfires that result from fuel accumulation. No landowner has ever been successfully sued for not conducting a prescribed burn that might have prevented a wildfire.

Fire ecologists and land managers argue that this liability imbalance creates a systematic bias against proactive fire management. When the expected cost of a prescribed burn escape (via litigation) exceeds the expected benefit of fuel reduction, risk-averse managers choose inaction โ€” and forests grow denser and more dangerous with each passing year.

Legislative Responses

The Fix Our Forests Act, currently under consideration in Congress, includes prescribed fire liability protections as a central provision. Several western states have also passed or are considering legislation to strengthen the legal shield for certified prescribed burn managers operating within approved burn plans.

Advocates argue that without meaningful liability reform at both the state and federal level, prescribed fire programs โ€” already hampered by limited capacity, narrow weather windows, and air quality constraints โ€” will continue to operate far below the scale needed to make a dent in accumulated fuel loads across the West.

Oregon fire managers completed a record number of prescribed burn acres in 2025 and had planned to expand further in 2026, but many planned burns were postponed or cancelled when weather conditions aligned during periods of elevated litigation concern. The result: more fuel in the ground heading into what proved to be a catastrophic fire season.